The Woman Who Fell to Earth Review (Spoiler Free)

By Kezia Newson

A real TARDIS, a red carpet entrance and the actual Doctor in the audience… not quite our normal viewing of Doctor Who! No pyjamas or cups of tea in sight.

Before the episode begins, I have a moment of reflection – this is the newest Doctor Who has been since, well arguably Rose. With not just a new Doctor, but new companions, a new showrunner and all-new crew. There will be girls and boys (and awkward 14 year-olds) starting their journey just as I did and falling in love with the show on October 7th, boy is that exciting.

The Woman Who Fell to Earth begins as a slow unfurl into our new reality of the show, something which is quite unexpected. There’s a sense of change coming in every word the characters speak, but we have time as an audience to settle into these new people we’re going to know so well. We live with them for a while, are given small pockets of who they are; and it’s a joy.

The cast, maybe unsurprisingly are what stand head and shoulders above anything else in this first episode from the Thirteenth Doctor. I never had any doubts, but Jodie Whittaker is truly everything that is the Doctor, and everything you want to see from a Doctor in their first episode. Post-regeneration and not quite knowing who she is yet, she knits her own existence together throughout the story, and her new friends seem to weave effortlessly into this recent incarnation, creating new foundations of Doctor.

These companions are never unneeded or in the way – this small gang of surprised humans all have their own skills, attitude and determination to be justified, and the dialogue between them is perfect. A warm, comfortable rhythm of relationships old and new, moulding around the strange situation they find themselves in. Each person is individual and wonderful, and I cannot wait to see more of them.

Screen Shot 2018-09-27 at 00.12.04.png

Jodie’s performance feels both familiar and unrecognisable, which is surely everything a new Doctor should be. In the Twelfth Doctor’s costume, she navigates who or what she is, with the subtlest hints of previous incarnations. Nothing is in-your-face Doctor Who, you just believe instantly that she is the same Time Lord as the one Patrick Troughton, Tom Baker and Matt Smith have played before her. This subtlety that Chris has got down so well means that truly anyone can watch The Woman Who Fell to Earth and not feel left behind. There are no ‘nudge nudge, wink wink’ moments, you simply feel the reverence and respect for the past, but this story is firmly placed in the here and now.

The light and dark in episode one show Chris’s strengths as a writer. It’s a brilliant balance that if gone too far either way would be on the cusp of something not quite right, and yet it oozes confidence in its choices. This is the point where it’s incredibly hard not to spoil anything, but feel reassured that while there are jokes, quips and moments of fun, this is Doctor Who that trusts its audience, whatever age to take it seriously. Scheduling wise, it’s nailed it. This is high-level, beautiful drama and sits proudly as a younger sibling next to the sought after 9pm slot.

This high-level feel is surely largely down to director Jamie Childs whose every shot is like nothing Doctor Who has been before. The impeccable pacing allows for tight shots on characters we would never have had real time to appreciate before; showcasing performance over quick wins, whilst stylistic choices such as the strong depth of field throw a contrast of human and not-so-human into stark horror for viewers.

And what is incredible drama without music? Segun Akinola’s score has a masterful effect on your blood pressure as it marries perfectly with the script and direction. It’s very ambient – contributing to the atmosphere of the story rather than demanding your attention. In this way it’s both humble and exciting, and absolutely what’s best for the show. Although other parts of episode one may not be shouting from the rooftops about its ancestry, Segun’s sampling of Delia Derbyshire’s work is such a treat it almost brings tears to your eyes.

And so we leave it there. The Woman Who Fell to Earth is not nervous or faltering – it crashes into our comfortable world of what we think Doctor Who is and raises the bar of what it could be. It’s slick, fun, warm and scary all at once, with fantastic performances and beautiful direction. We’re absolutely onboard and ready for all the adventures the Thirteenth Doctor and her friends want to take us on.

“I hope it demonstrates everything that you come to love about Doctor Who. There’s fun, there’s monsters, there’s action, adventure and an amazing new Doctor… What we’ve tried to do is show the range of what Doctor Who can do visually, emotionally and geographically through time and space… the whole range of everything.”
– Chris Chibnall at the Q&A event post screening

The Woman Who Fell to Earth will be broadcast on BBC One at 6:45pm, Sunday 7th October.

Published by


A blog for female Doctor Who fans, run by female Doctor Who fans.

15 thoughts on “The Woman Who Fell to Earth Review (Spoiler Free)”

  1. As a 50 year old man. This will be a big big change. A life long hero rarely changes gender. The stainless steel rat did it one of the books by Harry Harrison. I guess the doctor is gender fluid if I’m using the right term. So am I old school or am I down with the kids. I’m a Sci Fi fan. We push boundaries. Change is harder as you get older so I have been told. Roll on the future. I never beleaved my elders since I found out about father Christmas. Nice review. The time (lords) are a changing


  2. Really liked your review, plus the other things I’ve read about the new series looks like it’s going to be well worth the wait.


  3. I am and have always been (rarely – it seems – I know; as a mature both classic & modern whovian) always been right behind the casting of Jodie (as a huge prior fan since: ‘Venus’ onwards) so was already pretty excited. Somehow, reading 📚 this genuine, positive, insightful piece has taken that to another level! Really, really, great work. This review can best be described, in one single word: “FANTASTIC!!!” 😇😍😎


  4. Thank you for the review! I couldn’t be more excited about stepping over the threshold of the new season, new Doctor, new era… and very much look forward to reading and talking about it here!


  5. A wonderful review. I’m very excited to see what Jamie Childs and Segun Akinola do with the show, they both seem to be very talented up and comers in the industry. Can you comment on the cinematography? I’ve read that it’s very good, but nobody has really said anything else aside from that. Thanks a lot for posting and God bless you all. Here’s to a great series 11!


  6. I watched this first new episode with tears in my eyes. Explaining to my partner and child this morning, I said, I’ve been waiting for a Doctor who looks like me for 49 long years, and she’s finally arrived. I’ve been with the show since the very first time I saw my first Pertwee episode, and I’m excited about this bold step forward – what a great team/companions/friends the Doctor has assembled too…can’t wait to see how this season goes! Great Review!


  7. As an uber-casual DW viewer, I was pleased at the announcement of a female DW. The first few episodes have been decent and Jodie has filled the roll very well. In fact, I actually believe that the female DW will be one of the true feminist characters. In drama, most female characters are defined in some way by their romances, or lack of them. Jodie will play a female character who will be romance free. That is rare for female protagonists. (Although Sucker Punch did it with 5 of them).


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s